"Hollywood Reporter" and "Variety"

and, like almost EVERY MOVIE, they disagree. Variety's is negative (though not scathing), a surprisingly gives Kidman her first review that isn't glowing (though it seems his problem is more with the way the character is written). Hollywood Reporter is much more positive, only citing that some characters pop up a bit too suddenly (ie: the "jumpy editing" problem) but overall the film is a success.

Variety

Hollywood Reporter

this changes the tally to 9 good vs 3 bad